Make good in a commercial lease
A make good clause says what the tenant must do with the premises when the lease ends. This guide shows what to look for in the wording.
General information about the wording of leases. Not legal advice. Blox is a real estate agency, not a law firm.
What this clause usually sets out
A make good clause, also called reinstatement, sets out what the tenant must do with the premises at the end of the lease. The work can include removing fixtures, fittings and signage, repairing damage, and restoring the premises to a stated condition.
The clause says to what standard. It can refer to the condition at the start of the lease, to a base building condition, or to the landlord's reasonable satisfaction. Some leases attach a condition report or a schedule that lists the work. Others say nothing more than a general standard.
It sets the time. The clause can require the work to be finished before the expiry date, or before an earlier end of the lease, or within a number of days after the lease ends. When the end date can move, for example if an option is exercised, the deadline moves with it.
It says what happens if the tenant does not do the work. One form is that the landlord can do it and recover the cost from the tenant, and the clause can say whether rent keeps running while the work is done.
The clause also connects to others: the consent given for the tenant's alterations may say removal is required, and a security clause may allow the landlord to draw on the security to pay for work not done.
Make good also connects to the start of the lease. A lease can record the condition of the premises on the start date, through a condition report or a statement that the tenant takes the premises as they are. That record is what a standard such as "condition at the start" is measured against, so without one the standard is harder to pin down.
What to look for in the wording
These are points to check against the lease. None of them says what a particular lease means.
- The standard: original condition, base building condition, condition at the start date, or "reasonable satisfaction".
- Whether fair wear and tear is excepted.
- Whether the clause lists the work, or only states a general standard.
- Whether work done by an earlier tenant, or approved alterations, must also be removed.
- Whether the landlord must say what removal it requires, and by when.
- The deadline, and what it is counted from: expiry, an earlier end, or the day the tenant leaves.
- Whether rent or outgoings continue while the work is done.
- What the landlord can do if the work is not done, and how the cost is worked out.
- Whether the tenant can pay an agreed sum instead of doing the work.
- Whether a condition report exists for the start of the lease.
A worked example from the sample lease
The fictional sample lease has one make good clause.
Before the Expiry Date or earlier end of this Lease, the Tenant must remove its fixtures, fittings, equipment and signage, and make good any damage caused by their installation or removal, to the Landlord's reasonable satisfaction.
cl 10.1, page 4
- Stated: the deadline is "Before the Expiry Date or earlier end of this Lease".
- Worked out, no option taken up: the Expiry Date is 31 March 2028, so the work is due before 31 March 2028.
- Worked out, option taken up: the one year further term ends on 31 March 2029 (cl 4.1), so the work is due before 31 March 2029.
- The work named is removal of fixtures, fittings, equipment and signage, and repair of damage caused by installing or removing them.
- The only standard stated is "the Landlord's reasonable satisfaction".
The quoted sentence does not mention repainting, flooring or ceilings, and it does not say who decides what is reasonable if the parties disagree. Those are points to raise before the lease ends, not after.
The sample lease is fictional. Every party, address and figure in it is invented.
NSW references
The Blox lease review runs no Retail Leases Act check on make good, so this guide states no section of the Act.
Questions to raise with a solicitor
- What standard does the lease require, and is it described anywhere other than this clause?
- Does the clause cover work done by an earlier tenant or by the landlord, or only my own fit-out?
- When is the deadline, and does it move if the lease ends early or an option is taken up?
- Can the landlord require removal of something it approved when it was installed?
- If the landlord does the work, how is the cost worked out and how can I challenge it?
- Does rent continue while make good work is done?
Questions
What does make good mean?
It means the work a tenant must do at the end of a lease, such as removing fit-out and repairing damage, to the standard the lease sets out.
When is make good done?
The lease sets the time. It can be before the expiry date, before an earlier end of the lease, or within a stated number of days after it.
Does the lease review estimate the cost of make good?
No. The review shows what the clause says, the standard it states or leaves out, and the deadline. It does not put a dollar figure on the work.
Related
See the sample reportHow the checks workAll lease guidesLease review
Get the lease checklist
A checklist of the clauses and dates a Blox lease review looks for in a lease, with a box to tick for each one.
We email you a link to the checklist. It is general information about a lease, not legal advice.