Make good, NSW commercial leases

Make good clauses in NSW commercial leases

What a make good clause asks of a tenant, the standards leases use, and how a landlord records, schedules and enforces it from the first inspection.

  • NSW Licence 10103554

What a make good clause is

A make good clause is a term of a commercial lease that requires the tenant, at the end of the lease, to return the premises to a stated condition. That usually means removing the tenant’s fit-out and repairing damage, to a standard the lease names: base building, as at commencement, or fair wear and tear excepted. The wording of the clause decides what the tenant must do, and the condition record made at the start of the lease decides how a dispute is measured. This guide sets out the usual standards and how a NSW landlord schedules make good from the first inspection. A solicitor should confirm what a particular lease requires.

Empty warehouse interior with a polished concrete floor and roller doors
  • Lease clause

What standards do make good clauses use?

Most clauses name one of three standards, and some combine them. The lease definition governs, so read the exact words before relying on any label.

Base building

The tenant removes its fit-out and leaves the premises as the base building, the shell the landlord delivers. Partitions, ceilings, floor finishes, cabling and services added by the tenant come out, and the surfaces they touched are repaired. It asks the most of the tenant.

As at commencement

The tenant returns the premises to the condition recorded when the lease began. The landlord’s works stay, the tenant’s own works go, and the commencement condition report is the yardstick. Without that report the standard is hard to apply.

Fair wear and tear excepted

A qualifier rather than a standard on its own. It excuses ordinary deterioration from normal use and sits beside one of the standards above. The line between wear and tear and damage is a judgement call, so photographs and dated inspection notes matter.

  • Lease clause
  • Condition report

Why does the condition report at commencement decide everything?

An as at commencement clause can only be applied against a record of what was there on day one. If the landlord holds no report, the tenant’s memory and the landlord’s memory are the only evidence at handback, and neither is strong.

Hold a dated report, signed or acknowledged by both parties, with photographs of every room, the shopfront or entry, the floors, the services and any existing fit-out the landlord leaves in place. Record the landlord’s works separately from anything the tenant later installs.

Complete it at handover, not at signing, because the condition can change in between.

  • Lease clause
  • Inspections

How should a landlord schedule make good from the first inspection?

  1. Handover

    Condition report and photographs completed, acknowledged and filed with the lease.

  2. Each routine inspection

    Photograph and compare against the report. Record any alteration and check it has a written landlord consent.

  3. The notice date

    Many leases fix a date before expiry for the landlord to state its make good requirements. Diarise it from the lease abstract, not from memory.

  4. Handback inspection

    Inspect against the report and the clause, with the tenant where possible. Record each item as complete, incomplete or disputed.

  5. After handback

    Price any works, check the security held and take advice before any claim or deduction.

If a lease ends early by agreement, the deed should deal with make good. See our guide to surrender of lease.

  • Lease clause

What happens when the tenant does not make good?

The lease says what follows, and a solicitor should advise before a landlord acts. Leases commonly give the landlord a right to carry out the works and recover the cost, or to claim against security held under the lease. Whether a landlord can rely on those rights depends on the wording, on what the tenant did and did not do, and on any notice requirements in the lease.

Record first and act second. Dated photographs, a written list of outstanding items and quotes for the work give a solicitor what is needed to advise.

  • s 11(1)
  • Sch 2 Part 3
  • Sch 2 item 31
  • s 38

What applies to make good on retail shop leases?

The Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW) uses the words make good only once, in a question put to tenants in Schedule 2, but it touches the same ground in three places.

The disclosure statement. At least seven days before a retail shop lease is entered into, the lessor must give the tenant a disclosure statement in or to the effect of Parts A and B of Schedule 2 (section 11(1)). Part 3 of that form covers works, fit-out and refurbishment: the lessor’s works, the tenant’s fit-out works, and any lessor requirements for the quality and standard of the shop front and fit-out. Item 1.4 lists the existing structures, fixtures, plant and equipment the lessor provides.

The tenant’s acknowledgement. The form prompts the tenant to ask whether it must refurbish the premises regularly or at the end of the lease, and whether it must make good the premises at the end of the lease (Schedule 2, item 31). The clause should therefore be clear in the lease from the start.

Refurbishing and refitting. Under section 38, a provision requiring the lessee to refurbish or refit the shop is void unless it gives details of the nature, extent and timing of the work. Whether section 38 reaches a particular make good clause is a question for a solicitor.

The Act is covered in full in our Retail Leases Act NSW guide.

  • 7 daysMinimum notice for the disclosure statement before the lease is entered into
Vacant retail shop with a for lease sign in the window
  • Lease clause

How does make good work on industrial premises?

Industrial make good is mostly about structure and ground. The items to record at the start of the lease, and to check at handback, are:

  • Floor slab. Cracks, oil and chemical staining, and holes left by anchor bolts from racking and machinery.
  • Hardstand and yard. Surface damage, line marking, drainage pits and areas used for storage or vehicles.
  • Racking and equipment. Removal, with bolt holes made good and any slab patching recorded.
  • Services. Power, compressed air lines, switchboard changes, sprinkler heads and hardwired plant.
  • Doors, docks and amenities. Roller door operation, dock levellers and any tenant additions.

Take slab and hardstand photographs at handover with a scale reference such as a tape or marked grid. Make good on industrial premises is set out in the lease; Blox schedules it from the first inspection. For leasing, see warehouse and industrial leasing.

Aerial view of an industrial estate with warehouses and hardstand
  • Lease clause

What is the difference between make good and redecoration?

Make good deals with the tenant’s alterations and fit-out and, depending on the standard, damage. Redecoration is a separate covenant: painting, recarpeting or refinishing surfaces at stated intervals or at the end of the term. A lease can contain both, and they can overlap. Removing a partition, for example, leaves a wall to be repainted.

Read them as separate obligations with separate wording, and check whether the redecoration covenant applies during the term as well as at the end.

  • Property management

How does Blox manage make good for a landlord?

Make good sits inside commercial property management and does not start at handback. For each lease, Blox:

  • reads the make good clause and records its standard in the lease abstract
  • completes and files the commencement condition report with dated photographs
  • diarises the notice date and the handback inspection
  • checks each tenant alteration against a written landlord consent
  • runs the handback inspection and issues a written list of outstanding items
  • coordinates quotes for works and reports on the security held

The wider service is described under commercial property management.

Tool

Make good checklist builder

Pick the premises and the clause standard. The page assembles the inspection checklist and the documents to hold.

Premises
Clause standard

Inspection checklist

    Documents to hold

      FAQ

      Make good questions landlords ask

      What is a make good clause?

      A make good clause requires a tenant, at the end of the lease, to return the premises to a stated standard, usually by removing its fit-out and repairing damage. The standard might be base building, as at commencement, or fair wear and tear excepted. The exact words are in the lease.

      Who pays for make good?

      The lease decides. Make good clauses commonly require the tenant to carry out the works or meet their cost, but the wording, any agreed surrender terms and any waiver by the landlord can change that. A solicitor should confirm the position under a particular lease.

      Can a landlord demand a full strip out?

      Only to the extent the lease requires it. A base building clause can require removal of the tenant’s fit-out back to the shell. An as at commencement clause points back to the condition recorded on day one. For a retail shop, section 38 of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW) deals with requirements to refurbish or refit, and a solicitor should say whether it affects the clause.

      What if the tenant leaves without making good?

      Start with evidence: a handback inspection, dated photographs and a written list of outstanding items. Then check what the lease provides about carrying out the works, recovering the cost and any security held. A solicitor should advise before the landlord claims against security or against the tenant.

      Empty warehouse interior with a polished concrete floor and roller doors

      Who runs make good from the first inspection?

      A managing agent can record the commencement condition, diarise the notice and handback dates and run each inspection. Read about our commercial property management.

      Enquiry

      Ask about a make good clause

      Send the property address and the clause wording, or ask a general question.

      Vacant shop with a for lease sign

      This guide is general information. It is not legal advice. What a make good clause requires depends on the wording of the lease, and a solicitor should confirm it.

      Call 02 8883 4559Ask a question