When can a landlord refuse consent to an assignment?
For a retail shop lease, section 39(1) of the Retail Leases Act lists the grounds for withholding consent and says the landlord is not entitled to withhold it in any other circumstances. The grounds are: the assignee proposes to change the use of the shop; the assignee’s financial resources or retailing skills are inferior to the assignor’s; the tenant has not followed section 41; the airside airport ground in section 80E; and, for a lease awarded by public tender, the assignee failing the tender criteria.
Section 41 is the procedure. The tenant requests consent in writing and gives the information the landlord reasonably requires about the assignee’s financial resources and retailing skills (section 41(a), (b)). The landlord must give an updated disclosure statement within 14 days of being asked (41(d)). It then has 28 days to decide, counted from the request or from when the tenant complied, whichever is later (41(g)). If the tenant has complied and the landlord gives no written notice in that period, it is taken to have consented (41(h)). Regulations may replace the 28 days (41(i)).
For other commercial leases, section 133B of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) reads into a lease with a consent requirement a proviso that consent is not to be unreasonably withheld, while keeping the landlord’s right to a reasonable sum for legal or other expenses. Section 43 of the Retail Leases Act switches section 133B off for retail shop leases to the extent it is inconsistent. A solicitor should confirm whether a refusal is reasonable. The rest of the Act is in our Retail Leases Act NSW guide.