Market rent review guide

Market rent reviews and ratchet clauses in NSW commercial leases

A market rent review resets the rent in a commercial lease to the rent the market supports on a date the lease sets, and the rent can move up or down. A ratchet clause stops it falling. For retail shop leases, section 18 of the Retail Leases Act deals with ratchets directly.

  • NSW Licence 10103554

The short answer

A market rent review sets rent by evidence of what comparable premises lease for, where a fixed increase uses a stated figure and a CPI review follows an index. Which method applies, and when, is in the lease. For retail shop leases, section 18 of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW) restricts how often base rent changes, voids a discretion over the choice of method and voids a provision that prevents rent decreasing on a review that could lower it. For other commercial leases the lease governs, and a solicitor should confirm how a clause operates.

  • Lease review clause

What is a market rent review, and how does it differ from CPI and fixed increases?

Fixed increase

How rent changes
By a stated percentage or amount on stated dates.
Direction
Up by the stated figure.

CPI review

How rent changes
By the movement in an index named in the lease.
Direction
Follows the index. Check for a floor or a cap.

Market review

How rent changes
Reset to the market rent on the review date.
Direction
Up or down.

A market rent review resets rent to what the market supports on a date the lease sets. The evidence is leasing deals for comparable premises, adjusted for incentives such as rent free periods, so the figure is an effective rent and not a headline asking rent. Market reviews commonly fall at option renewals, at fixed points in a long lease or during renewal negotiations.

A CPI review is arithmetic, and the CPI rent increase calculator works it out. A fixed rent increase needs no evidence, only the figure and the dates in the lease. Check which method applies at each review date, because one lease can use different methods at different points.

  • Lease review clause

What is a ratchet clause, and why do landlords want one?

A ratchet clause lets rent go up on a review but never down. If the review method is market rent and the market has fallen, the rent stays at its previous level. Landlords want one for certainty, because it protects the rent already achieved and the income the landlord budgets on. Tenants resist it because it removes the benefit of a falling market.

A cap limits how far rent can rise on a review and a collar limits how far it can fall, so a collar can work like a ratchet. For a lease outside the Retail Leases Act, the lease governs whether a ratchet, cap or collar applies, and a solicitor should confirm how a particular clause operates.

  • s 18(1)
  • s 18(2)
  • s 18(3)
  • s 18(4)

What does section 18 of the Retail Leases Act say about ratchets?

Section 18 is headed Restrictions on adjustment of base rent. Base rent is rent, or the component of rent, that comprises a specified amount of money. Turnover rent is not base rent (section 18(1)).

Section 18(2) says a retail shop lease must not provide for a change to base rent less than 12 months after the lease is entered into or after any previous change. It does not apply to a change by a specified amount or specified percentage.

Section 18(3) makes a provision void to the extent that it reserves a discretion as to which of 2 or more methods applies on a particular occasion, reserves a discretion as to whether the rent changes in accordance with a method, or provides for the change by whichever method would result in the higher or highest rent.

Section 18(4) applies where a lease provides for a change that could cause rent to decrease, such as a change to current market rent. A provision is void to the extent that it prevents, or enables the lessor or any other person to prevent, base rent decreasing, or limits or specifies the amount by which it is to decrease. Use the decoder to see how the wording in a lease lines up. The wider Act is in our Retail Leases Act NSW guide.

Review method decoder

What does the review clause say?

The wording decoded

What it means

What governs it

Check in the lease

    • s 18(2) to (4)

    How much can commercial rent increase in NSW?

    By the method the lease names. For a lease outside the Retail Leases Act, the lease governs how and when rent changes, and a solicitor should confirm whether any limit applies to a particular lease.

    For a retail shop lease, section 18 as read above restricts how often base rent changes, who chooses the method and whether rent can be stopped from falling. It does not set a maximum amount for an increase. A fixed percentage or amount is outside the 12 month rule in section 18(2), and a CPI increase follows the index.

    • s 31(1)
    • s 31(2)

    How is market rent worked out for a retail shop?

    Section 31(1)(a) says current market rent is the rent that would reasonably be expected to be paid for the shop as between a willing lessor and a willing lessee in an arm’s length transaction, determined on an effective rent basis. It takes account of matters that include rent concessions and other benefits frequently offered to prospective lessees of unoccupied retail shops, and it does not take into account the value of goodwill created by the lessee’s occupation or of the lessee’s fixtures and fittings.

    If the parties do not agree, a specialist retail valuer decides, appointed by agreement or, failing agreement, by the Registrar (section 31(1)(b)). The lessor must give the valuer requested information about comparable leases in the same building or centre within 14 days of the request, where reasonably available (31(1)(d)). The valuation is in writing with detailed reasons (31(1)(e)), the parties pay the cost in equal shares (31(1)(f)), and the valuer must act within 1 month of receiving the information (31(2)).

    • Lease review clause

    Where do market rent reviews go wrong?

    Review clauses run on strict timetables, so diarise every trigger date, response window and deadline. The usual failures are these.

    • The notice window closes. Some clauses treat silence as acceptance, so a missed response can settle the rent.
    • The notice is defective, with the wrong method of service, address or content.
    • Face rent is mistaken for market rent, when incentives such as rent free periods change the effective rent.
    • There is no comparable evidence, which hands control to the party that has it.
    • The budget assumes rent can only rise.
    • Flow-on items are forgotten, such as a bank guarantee top up, the outgoings budget and option terms. See the guide to a bank guarantee for a commercial lease.
    • Property management

    How does Blox run a market rent review?

    Blox Commercial starts with the clause: the method, the dates and the notice requirements. It diarises the critical dates, prepares and serves the notice in the form the lease requires, builds the evidence with an effective rent analysis, negotiates, and closes out by recording the new rent and updating invoicing and flow-on items. Blox is a licensed real estate agency and not a valuer or a law firm, so a formal determination goes to a specialist retail valuer and a legal question goes to a solicitor.

    Reviews are offered at four levels.

    Level 1: Verification

    What it covers
    A review of the clause and a check of the calculation.

    Level 2: Rent review administration

    What it covers
    Verification, plus formal notices, rent schedule updates and diary management. Suited to CPI and fixed reviews.

    Level 3: Market evidence and negotiation

    What it covers
    An evidence pack, effective rent analysis and negotiation. Suited to market reviews.

    Level 4: Full representation

    What it covers
    End to end management of the review, including coordination with a valuer or solicitor where one is needed.

    FAQ

    Market rent review questions

    What is a market rent review?

    A market rent review resets the rent in a lease to the rent the market supports on a date the lease sets, based on evidence of comparable premises. The rent can go up or down, depending on the lease.

    What is a ratchet clause in a commercial lease?

    A ratchet clause lets rent rise on a review but never fall. For retail shop leases, section 18(4) of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW) makes a provision void to the extent that it prevents base rent decreasing where the lease provides for a change that could cause a decrease.

    How much can commercial rent increase in NSW?

    By the method the lease names. For retail shop leases, section 18 restricts the timing and structure of changes but does not set a maximum amount. For other commercial leases the lease governs, and a solicitor should confirm.

    What is the difference between a fixed rent increase, CPI and a market review?

    A fixed increase raises rent by a stated figure on stated dates. A CPI review follows an index named in the lease. A market review resets rent to the market rent on the review date and can move it up or down.

    Want this run for you?

    Blox manages and leases commercial property for NSW landlords.

    Who runs the review for the landlord?

    Blox Commercial diarises, serves and negotiates rent reviews as part of commercial property management.

    Enquiry

    Ask Blox to run your next rent review

    Send the lease and the review date.

    Retail shop strip at dusk

    Useful to send

    • The lease and any variations
    • The review clause and date
    • Current rent and the last review
    • Any notice already received

    This guide is general information about the law in NSW. It is not legal advice. A solicitor should confirm how it applies to a particular lease. The Retail Leases Act sections cited are the Act as in force, and a Bill to amend it, the Retail Leases Amendment (Review) Bill 2025, is before Parliament.

    Call 02 8883 4559Ask a question