Lease disputes guide

Commercial lease disputes in NSW: how a landlord resolves them

Most commercial lease disputes are settled by following the lease first: its notices, its dispute clause and a clean paper trail. For retail shop leases the Retail Leases Act adds mediation before proceedings and a Tribunal route. Other commercial leases rely on the lease and the general law.

  • NSW Licence 10103554

The short answer

Most disputes begin as a disagreement about money or condition: rent, outgoings, make good or repairs. The landlord’s first tools are the lease’s own notice provisions and a clear record. For retail shop leases, section 68 of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW) requires mediation to be tried before court proceedings, and section 71 lets a party lodge a retail tenancy claim with the Tribunal. That route is for retail shop leases. Other commercial leases follow the lease’s dispute clause and the general law, and a solicitor should confirm the route for a particular lease.

  • Lease clause

What are the most common commercial lease disputes?

The disputes landlords meet most are rent arrears, outgoings, make good, repairs, a refused assignment, an option notice and an abandoned tenancy. Each has a different first step, and what follows depends on whether the lease is a retail shop lease. Pick the dispute below to see the usual path. It shows the route and does not assess a claim.

Dispute navigator

What is the dispute about?

The retail route applies to retail shop leases only. Check which kind of lease you hold first. See the Retail Leases Act NSW guide.

The usual path

First, under the lease

    Then, for this type of lease

      Keep on file

        • Conv. Act s 129(1), (2)

        Rent arrears: what can a landlord do first?

        Start with the lease. The rent and default clauses say when rent is due, what counts as a default and how much notice the tenant gets. Many leases set their own period for the tenant to pay after a notice, so the period is the lease’s own and not a fixed statutory one.

        Before a landlord acts on a right of re-entry or forfeiture, section 129(1) of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) says the right is not enforceable unless the lessor has served a notice specifying the breach, requiring the lessee to remedy it if it can be remedied, and requiring compensation if the lessor claims it, and the lessee fails within a reasonable time. A solicitor should confirm each step before a breach notice goes out.

        Keep a clear rent record, because the invoice is the first piece of evidence. See the FAQ on the monthly rental invoice.

        • s 22(1)

        How are outgoings disputes resolved?

        Most outgoings disputes come down to the budget, the reconciliation and the supporting invoices. Check the outgoings clause for what is recoverable and how it is apportioned.

        For a retail shop lease, section 22(1) of the Retail Leases Act says the tenant is not liable to pay outgoings except in accordance with lease provisions that specify the recoverable outgoings, how they are determined and apportioned, and how they may be recovered. Answer queries in writing, attach the invoices and use the outgoings calculator to check the workings.

        • Lease clause

        Make good disputes: what does a landlord need to show?

        Make good disputes turn on the lease clause and the evidence of condition at the start and the end. Keep the condition report, dated photographs and a written schedule of the work, with quotes. The bank guarantee often secures the obligation, so check its expiry before the dispute runs on. See make good in a commercial lease and the guide to a bank guarantee for a commercial lease.

        • s 63
        • s 65(1)(a)
        • s 68(1) to (3)

        Is mediation compulsory in a commercial lease dispute?

        For retail shop leases, mediation comes first. Section 68(1) says a retail tenancy dispute may not be the subject of proceedings before any court unless and until the Registrar has certified in writing that mediation has failed, or the court is otherwise satisfied that mediation is unlikely to resolve it. Part 8 defines court to include a tribunal (section 63). The Registrar must certify failure if a party has refused to take part or has withdrawn (section 68(2)), and the requirement does not apply to court proceedings for an injunction (section 68(3)).

        The Registrar of Retail Tenancy Disputes, who sits within the NSW Small Business Commission, makes the arrangements for mediation (section 65(1)(a)). For other commercial leases, mediation is compulsory only if the lease or a court order requires it. The parties can still agree to use a private mediator.

        • s 70
        • s 71(1), (2)
        • s 71A

        What does NCAT handle for retail leases?

        Division 3 of Part 8 is headed Determination of claims by Civil and Administrative Tribunal. Section 71(1) lets a party or former party to a retail shop lease lodge a retail tenancy claim with the Tribunal. Section 71(2) says a claim may not be lodged more than 3 years after the liability or obligation arose.

        Section 70 lists the claims, including payment of money, relief from payment, doing specified work, surrender of possession, a declaration that a lessor is not entitled to withhold consent to an assignment, relief against forfeiture and entitlement to a security bond. Section 71A covers unconscionable conduct claims under section 62B. Other commercial leases are outside Part 8, so a solicitor should confirm the forum.

        • Not legal advice

        When should a landlord involve a solicitor?

        Involve one before any notice that could end the lease, before any lock out or re-entry, before a demand on a guarantee the tenant disputes, and before lodging anything with the Tribunal or a court. Blox is a licensed real estate agency, not a law firm, and does not give legal advice. A solicitor should confirm the notices, forum and time limits for the lease in question.

        • Property management

        How does Blox manage lease disputes?

        Most disputes grow from missing records. Blox Commercial keeps the rent ledger and invoices, diarises the lease’s critical dates, drafts and serves notices in the form the lease requires, and keeps a dated file of every request and reply. It also keeps the tenant relationship working while a dispute runs, and briefs the landlord’s solicitor when one is needed.

        FAQ

        Lease dispute questions

        What are the most common commercial lease disputes in NSW?

        Rent arrears, outgoings, make good, repairs, a refused assignment, an option notice and an abandoned tenancy. Each starts with the lease’s own clause and notice provisions.

        Is mediation compulsory for a commercial lease dispute?

        For retail shop leases, section 68(1) of the Retail Leases Act 1994 (NSW) says a retail tenancy dispute may not be the subject of court proceedings until the Registrar certifies that mediation has failed, or the court is otherwise satisfied it is unlikely to resolve the dispute. For other commercial leases, the lease decides.

        What does NCAT handle for retail leases?

        Under section 71(1) of the Retail Leases Act, a party can lodge a retail tenancy claim with the Tribunal, and section 70 lists the kinds of claim. A claim may not be lodged more than 3 years after the liability or obligation arose (section 71(2)).

        What is a breach notice for a commercial lease?

        A breach notice tells the tenant which breach is complained of and what must be done to remedy it. Under section 129(1) of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW), a right of re-entry or forfeiture is not enforceable until a notice of that kind is served and the tenant fails to remedy within a reasonable time. A solicitor should confirm the notice before it is served.

        Who keeps the lease records in order for the landlord?

        Blox Commercial runs the rent ledger, notices and tenant relationship as part of commercial property management.

        Enquiry

        Ask a lease question

        Send the lease details and your question.

        Neighbourhood shopping centre frontage

        Useful to send

        • The lease and any variations
        • Notices sent or received
        • The rent ledger
        • What the tenant has said so far

        This guide is general information about the law in NSW. It is not legal advice. A solicitor should confirm how it applies to a particular lease. The Retail Leases Act sections cited are the Act as in force, and a Bill to amend it, the Retail Leases Amendment (Review) Bill 2025, is before Parliament.

        Call 02 8883 4559Ask a question